The US Senate voted 50-47 to confirm Nicole G. Berner, a Maryland labor lawyer, as the first openly gay judge on the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
What does sexual preference have to do with an appointment unless personal desires are to be partial to judgements?
Republicans initially voiced opposition to her nomination, referring to a union brief she signed in 2017. However, Democrats supported her citing her endorsement by major labor unions and civil rights groups.
Maryland Senators Chris Van Hollen and Ben Cardin endorsed Berner, highlighting her extensive legal experience and qualification for the role.
The 4th Circuit Court, where Berner will serve, is based in Richmond, Virginia, and oversees cases from federal district courts in several states, including Maryland.
Berner’s confirmation marks a milestone as the third openly LGBTQ+ woman appointed to a federal appellate court, adding diversity and representation to the judiciary system.
Her legal background includes work on significant cases such as defending the Affordable Care Act and serving Planned Parenthood as a staff attorney.
Despite opposition from some Republicans related to her stance on certain labor issues, Berner emphasized the importance of a judge’s impartiality and commitment to applying legal precedent without bias.
Democrats’ slight Senate majority enabled Berner’s confirmation, emphasizing the political dynamics at play in judicial appointments.
Alongside Berner, President Biden also nominated Adeel Mangi to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, who, if confirmed, would be the first Muslim American judge on a circuit court.
